How the World Works

The audacity of free trade

Was it only a month ago that NAFTA-gate exploded all over Barack Obama and sunk any small chance he might have had of minimizing Hillary Clinton's margin of victory in Ohio? It seems like a lifetime gone by, centuries before the Age of Jeremiah Wright and the great Bosnian sniper fiasco. But what's really amazing is that, as far as I recall, during that whole frenzy of trade-related economic posturing by both candidates, nobody in the blogosphere thought to go back and see exactly what Obama said about trade and jobs in his book, "The Audacity of Hope."

On Sunday, Jonathan Dingel addressed this sad state of affairs in his blog Trade Diversion, and uploaded the relevant passages from pages 172-176 of the paperback edition.

The entirety of Obama's comments, along with Dingel's analysis, are worth reading in full. But for the purposes of How the World Works, here's the meat:

We can try to slow globalization, but we can't stop it. The U.S. economy is now so integrated with the rest of the world, and digital commerce so widespread, that it's hard to even imagine, much less enforce, an effective regime of protectionism. A tariff on imported steel may give temporary relief to U.S. steel producers, but it will make every U.S. manufacturer that uses steel in its products less competitive on the world market...

I told the President that I believed in the benefits of trade... But I said that resistance to CAFTA had less to do with the specifics of the agreement and more to do with the growing insecurities of the American worker. Unless we found strategies to allay those fears, and sent a strong signal to American workers that the federal government was on their side, protectionist sentiment would only grow...

I ended up voting against CAFTA... My vote gave me no satisfaction, but I felt it was the only way to register a protest against what I considered to be the White House's inattention to the losers from free trade.

Such sentiments are considerably more muted than the rhetoric Obama employed while stumping his way through Ohio, or that he is likely to deliver as he works his way through Pennsylvania. He probably isn't emphasizing, right now, how little "satisfaction" he took from voting against CAFTA. But his point is clear: free trade is a political albatross in the United States because the "losers" feel screwed by a government that doesn't appear to care. You can be pro-trade and still appreciate that reality.

Uncle Sam needs to go shopping. Not us
You want that discounted flat-screen TV. You want to help boost the economy. But I've got news for you.
Dow plunges again, Friedman fans despair
Despite the best efforts of the Federal Reserve to follow the economic prescriptions of Milton Friedman, nothing is working. But Keynes' stock is rising.
It's official: We're in a recession
Remember when Phil Gramm said Americans were a "nation of whiners"? He was wrong. The recession started last December.
The month the U.S. economy died
More bad numbers emerge detailing October's meltdown. Investors respond: The Dow goes into free fall.

About How the World Works

A conversation about globalization.

Recent Posts

Dow plunges again, Friedman fans despair
Despite the best efforts of the Federal Reserve to follow the economic prescriptions of Milton Friedman, nothing is working. But Keynes' stock is rising.
It's official: We're in a recession
Remember when Phil Gramm said Americans were a "nation of whiners"? He was wrong. The recession started last December.
The month the U.S. economy died
More bad numbers emerge detailing October's meltdown. Investors respond: The Dow goes into free fall.

Full Archive

RSS Feed

Posts by date

December 2008
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031

Comments?

You can e-mail me directly at aleonard@salon.com. But to join the conversation with your comments, please use our letters to the editor feature at the bottom of each article.